Depends on the rest of the room, but I like the stacked stone better.

If the hearth is not getting changed then the woven.. if the hearth is getting changed i like the stacked stone.

Neither but the woven is classic and will look better. In my opinion using the woven or the stacked on the floor will not be ideal.

Thanks for your comments. We will choose a smooth matching tile for the floor part. We have just painted the mantel white (it used to stained a honey hue). I personally want to like the stacked stone best but as I am looking at it I a leaning towards the woven one... Maybe if we reprinted the mantel in a bit more of an off white color it would look better...

I find the one you already have much better if I may say. I can't decide on the two choices given as I can't visualize how they would look.

Ugh, the hunter green tile is most definitely going!

I like the stacked stone as it is more modern. If your room is more on the traditional side, the woven will look better in your space.

Which ever one you choose. Bring out the hearth past the legs of the mantel.