The placement of your pendants seems wrong. Is it just the picture, or do they line up with the edges of your island?

@lucky998877 the picture makes it look a little weird, but the edge of it falls about 6.5-7" from the edge of the counter. The new ones would be about 5.5-6" smaller in diameter so they'd be a little closer in towards the middle. I think the "hole" (not sure the right term) where it attaches to the ceiling is about 15" from the edge of the counter.

The two smaller pendants will fit the space better. They are very pretty!

Hope this helps!

Keep in mind the glass globes will feel far less visually heavy than your current pendants.

@User That is super helpful, thank you!

Two pendants half that size, you outlet placement was centered to be that way. What you have now is much to large and in charge, the black also seems heavy. I would consider glass or mixed metal. Do not add a third pendant. Too much clutter.

I would have done this

We think it would be better to hang 3 pendant lights, but smaller than the ones in your photo.

If oyu have large and heavy pendants; use two. Light and small; Use three.

there is an 8" option available. Since they are glass globes, they will provide sufficient illumination if you choose the correct bulb. so you could place 3 8" globes. Three trumps two in most things anyway. Sets of three look better, IMO.