I'm thinking something like the attached.

sounds like that would work to me

That sounds logical. Is there a sink or cooktop in the island? If yes, you might consider how important task lighting might be and rethink how you lay out the lighting.

If you put pendants, just make sure to hang them at the right height, so you don't bump your forehead on them whale cooking!

*while

Can you include a photo of your kitchen? Lights in this situation are a great decorating opportunity for adding character to an otherwise rather neutrally decorated kitchen.

I don't really have a photo as it is being built now but will try to find a photo of a similar model.

There will be a large undermount sink on the island.

What is a good height to hang - I guess will depend on my lanterns but we have 10' ceilings.

We usually loop wire (I think this is what they call it) in the island area, then get the exact location after cabinets are installed, often even waiting for tops. Do you have your cabinet layout?

Representative kitchen layout is below for layout reference - my finishes are broke too - white shaker perimeter cabinets and dove gray island with quartz Carrara looking countertops.

I'm planning on doing 2 larger simple polished or brushed nickel lanterns.

Thanks for help!

So, the cabinets are light grey and white with light countertops. What color is your floor? The lanterns add a traditional or colonial vibe. Keep in mind, they will be a bit of a focal point and should be in keeping with the decorating theme of your kitchen as well as adjoining rooms.

Will have dark wood floors and white subway tile backsplash with gray grout.

My decorating style is definitely more traditional with a twist.

I agree, sounds like it would work.