HAHAH this was my first reaction to reading the OP. They are going to tell her to remove it and then add another mirror!! 🤦🤦🤦🤦🤦If you are selling in 6mos I would do nothing. Don't mess with what isn't going to be yours all that long.

I would remove them all.

If you’re selling within 6 months I would do nothing ( some people ,not me, like them ). I had mirrors removed in my previous home, depending upon how they’re affixed , I had to have my walls drywalled again. That larger one is awful.

In that case, I’d return rug, get the space finished before deciding.

Lovely space! I think your mosaic tile border already reads as a rug so I’d vote to do no rug OR splurge for a custom rug that fit perfectly with the mosaic.

Coming back to say that what you've achieved is magnificent in my book, ttodd.

It does seem a shame to cover any of that gorgeous tile with a waterhog mat, but unless you have the servants who daily used to clean a house of that apparent vintage, a walk-off mat of some sort is a practical addition. It will help keep the worst of the outside dirt in the vestibule, and prevent its being tracked into the house.

It's fabulous! I agree with others, please don't cover the floor!!!

Contact Bedrosians. Slab incidents during install do happen. They may just replace the slab.

How to Determine Responsibility & Next Step

File a Warranty / Rep Claim . Contact Bedrosians to inspect the broken slab. A manufacturer rep will evaluate whether the fracture was caused by factory tension or fabrication procedure

Check Fabricator Approval . Ensure your fabricator is certified or trained to cut Bedrosians porcelain, as warranties often require adherence to strict manufacturer fabrication manuals.

If Bedrosians determines the slab met factory quality standards, the fabricator is typically responsible for replacing the material.

If Bedrosians confirms a defect or batch tension issue, they will issue a replacement slab.

Is your fabricator certified by B or trained by B? Can he show valid certification or training from another manufacturer.? You have no personal direct evidence or knowledge of any other successful work on equivalent product.

Get a list from B of certified trained fabricators in your area. Talk to one of them about your project.

I do have personal knowledge that he cuts these type of slabs with no problem. Also the rep with Bedrosians stated I as the customer should have done better research on their product. Does not sound like good customer service to me!

Or can the TV be lowered and another shelf added?

To my eyes, this relationship between the TV and its space is better. And maybe having something to look at other than just a TV is not a bad thing?