Since the two open shelves worked well for you for five years, I would rebuild them instead of adding two large upper cabinets simply because the wall is open now.
The black window and Urban Bronze shiplap already give the sink wall a strong focal point. Large cabinets on both sides could make the window feel boxed in, while substantial wood shelves would keep the wall balanced and preserve the lighter appearance you previously enjoyed.
We used a similar approach in this Torrance kitchen, where the open shelving, window, sink, cabinetry and surrounding finishes were designed as one composition. The completed-project photos may help you visualize how shelves can frame the window without making the wall feel unfinished:
I am not a fan of open shelving but the idea Emily posted is a nice compromise and please take those cabinets to the ceiling
Since the two open shelves worked well for you for five years, I would rebuild them instead of adding two large upper cabinets simply because the wall is open now.
The black window and Urban Bronze shiplap already give the sink wall a strong focal point. Large cabinets on both sides could make the window feel boxed in, while substantial wood shelves would keep the wall balanced and preserve the lighter appearance you previously enjoyed.
We used a similar approach in this Torrance kitchen, where the open shelving, window, sink, cabinetry and surrounding finishes were designed as one composition. The completed-project photos may help you visualize how shelves can frame the window without making the wall feel unfinished:
https://overlandremodeling.com/kitchens-gallery/traditional-kitchen-torrance-ca
I would repeat a wood tone from the coffee bar and use a durable, washable finish on the shiplap, especially around the sink and countertop.